[compiler] Hook in compare op builtins with feedback in generic lowering

If --turbo-nci is enabled, use compare op builtins with feedback
collection during generic lowering.

Bug: v8:8888
Change-Id: I886020e2ee280f65388d9987c70958546f99e0f3
Reviewed-on: https://chromium-review.googlesource.com/c/v8/v8/+/2215821Reviewed-by: Georg Neis <neis@chromium.org>
Commit-Queue: Jakob Gruber <jgruber@chromium.org>
Cr-Commit-Position: refs/heads/master@{#68100}

src/codegen/x64/interface-descriptors-x64.cc

@@ -324,7 +324,7 @@ void BinaryOp_WithFeedbackDescriptor::InitializePlatformSpecific(
     CallInterfaceDescriptorData* data) {
   Register registers[] = {rdx,   // kLeft
                           rax,   // kRight
-                          rdi,   // Slot
+                          rdi,   // kSlot
                           rbx};  // kMaybeFeedbackVector
   data->InitializePlatformSpecific(arraysize(registers), registers);
 }
@@ -342,7 +342,7 @@ void Compare_WithFeedbackDescriptor::InitializePlatformSpecific(
     CallInterfaceDescriptorData* data) {
   Register registers[] = {rdx,   // kLeft
                           rax,   // kRight
-                          rdi,   // Slot
+                          rdi,   // kSlot
                           rbx};  // kMaybeFeedbackVector
   data->InitializePlatformSpecific(arraysize(registers), registers);
 }

src/compiler/bytecode-graph-builder.cc

@@ -247,10 +247,6 @@ class BytecodeGraphBuilder {
   // type feedback.
   BinaryOperationHint GetBinaryOperationHint(int operand_index);
 
-  // Helper function to create compare operation hint from the recorded
-  // type feedback.
-  CompareOperationHint GetCompareOperationHint();
-
   // Helper function to create for-in mode from the recorded type feedback.
   ForInMode GetForInMode(int operand_index);
 
@@ -443,10 +439,11 @@ class BytecodeGraphBuilder {
 
   TickCounter* const tick_counter_;
 
-  static int const kBinaryOperationHintIndex = 1;
-  static int const kCountOperationHintIndex = 0;
-  static int const kBinaryOperationSmiHintIndex = 1;
-  static int const kUnaryOperationHintIndex = 0;
+  static constexpr int kBinaryOperationHintIndex = 1;
+  static constexpr int kBinaryOperationSmiHintIndex = 1;
+  static constexpr int kCompareOperationHintIndex = 1;
+  static constexpr int kCountOperationHintIndex = 0;
+  static constexpr int kUnaryOperationHintIndex = 0;
 
   DISALLOW_COPY_AND_ASSIGN(BytecodeGraphBuilder);
 };
@@ -2761,14 +2758,6 @@ BinaryOperationHint BytecodeGraphBuilder::GetBinaryOperationHint(
   return broker()->GetFeedbackForBinaryOperation(source);
 }
 
-// Helper function to create compare operation hint from the recorded type
-// feedback.
-CompareOperationHint BytecodeGraphBuilder::GetCompareOperationHint() {
-  FeedbackSlot slot = bytecode_iterator().GetSlotOperand(1);
-  FeedbackSource source(feedback_vector(), slot);
-  return broker()->GetFeedbackForCompareOperation(source);
-}
-
 // Helper function to create for-in mode from the recorded type feedback.
 ForInMode BytecodeGraphBuilder::GetForInMode(int operand_index) {
   FeedbackSlot slot = bytecode_iterator().GetSlotOperand(operand_index);
@@ -3014,27 +3003,39 @@ void BytecodeGraphBuilder::BuildCompareOp(const Operator* op) {
 }
 
 void BytecodeGraphBuilder::VisitTestEqual() {
-  BuildCompareOp(javascript()->Equal(GetCompareOperationHint()));
+  FeedbackSource feedback = CreateFeedbackSource(
+      bytecode_iterator().GetSlotOperand(kCompareOperationHintIndex).ToInt());
+  BuildCompareOp(javascript()->Equal(feedback));
 }
 
 void BytecodeGraphBuilder::VisitTestEqualStrict() {
-  BuildCompareOp(javascript()->StrictEqual(GetCompareOperationHint()));
+  FeedbackSource feedback = CreateFeedbackSource(
+      bytecode_iterator().GetSlotOperand(kCompareOperationHintIndex).ToInt());
+  BuildCompareOp(javascript()->StrictEqual(feedback));
 }
 
 void BytecodeGraphBuilder::VisitTestLessThan() {
-  BuildCompareOp(javascript()->LessThan(GetCompareOperationHint()));
+  FeedbackSource feedback = CreateFeedbackSource(
+      bytecode_iterator().GetSlotOperand(kCompareOperationHintIndex).ToInt());
+  BuildCompareOp(javascript()->LessThan(feedback));
 }
 
 void BytecodeGraphBuilder::VisitTestGreaterThan() {
-  BuildCompareOp(javascript()->GreaterThan(GetCompareOperationHint()));
+  FeedbackSource feedback = CreateFeedbackSource(
+      bytecode_iterator().GetSlotOperand(kCompareOperationHintIndex).ToInt());
+  BuildCompareOp(javascript()->GreaterThan(feedback));
 }
 
 void BytecodeGraphBuilder::VisitTestLessThanOrEqual() {
-  BuildCompareOp(javascript()->LessThanOrEqual(GetCompareOperationHint()));
+  FeedbackSource feedback = CreateFeedbackSource(
+      bytecode_iterator().GetSlotOperand(kCompareOperationHintIndex).ToInt());
+  BuildCompareOp(javascript()->LessThanOrEqual(feedback));
 }
 
 void BytecodeGraphBuilder::VisitTestGreaterThanOrEqual() {
-  BuildCompareOp(javascript()->GreaterThanOrEqual(GetCompareOperationHint()));
+  FeedbackSource feedback = CreateFeedbackSource(
+      bytecode_iterator().GetSlotOperand(kCompareOperationHintIndex).ToInt());
+  BuildCompareOp(javascript()->GreaterThanOrEqual(feedback));
 }
 
 void BytecodeGraphBuilder::VisitTestReferenceEqual() {

src/compiler/js-generic-lowering.cc

@@ -73,12 +73,7 @@ REPLACE_STUB_CALL(BitwiseXor)
 REPLACE_STUB_CALL(ShiftLeft)
 REPLACE_STUB_CALL(ShiftRight)
 REPLACE_STUB_CALL(ShiftRightLogical)
-REPLACE_STUB_CALL(LessThan)
-REPLACE_STUB_CALL(LessThanOrEqual)
-REPLACE_STUB_CALL(GreaterThan)
-REPLACE_STUB_CALL(GreaterThanOrEqual)
 REPLACE_STUB_CALL(HasProperty)
-REPLACE_STUB_CALL(Equal)
 REPLACE_STUB_CALL(ToLength)
 REPLACE_STUB_CALL(ToNumber)
 REPLACE_STUB_CALL(ToNumberConvertBigInt)
@@ -136,18 +131,13 @@ void JSGenericLowering::ReplaceWithRuntimeCall(Node* node,
   NodeProperties::ChangeOp(node, common()->Call(call_descriptor));
 }
 
-void JSGenericLowering::LowerJSStrictEqual(Node* node) {
-  // The === operator doesn't need the current context.
-  NodeProperties::ReplaceContextInput(node, jsgraph()->NoContextConstant());
-  Callable callable = Builtins::CallableFor(isolate(), Builtins::kStrictEqual);
-  node->RemoveInput(4);  // control
-  ReplaceWithStubCall(node, callable, CallDescriptor::kNoFlags,
-                      Operator::kEliminatable);
-}
-
 void JSGenericLowering::ReplaceUnaryOpWithBuiltinCall(
     Node* node, Builtins::Name builtin_without_feedback,
     Builtins::Name builtin_with_feedback) {
+  DCHECK(node->opcode() == IrOpcode::kJSBitwiseNot ||
+         node->opcode() == IrOpcode::kJSDecrement ||
+         node->opcode() == IrOpcode::kJSIncrement ||
+         node->opcode() == IrOpcode::kJSNegate);
   const FeedbackParameter& p = FeedbackParameterOf(node->op());
   CallDescriptor::Flags flags = FrameStateFlagForCall(node);
   if (CollectFeedbackInGenericLowering() && p.feedback().IsValid()) {
@@ -181,6 +171,65 @@ DEF_UNARY_LOWERING(Increment)
 DEF_UNARY_LOWERING(Negate)
 #undef DEF_UNARY_LOWERING
 
+void JSGenericLowering::ReplaceCompareOpWithBuiltinCall(
+    Node* node, Builtins::Name builtin_without_feedback,
+    Builtins::Name builtin_with_feedback) {
+  DCHECK(node->opcode() == IrOpcode::kJSEqual ||
+         node->opcode() == IrOpcode::kJSGreaterThan ||
+         node->opcode() == IrOpcode::kJSGreaterThanOrEqual ||
+         node->opcode() == IrOpcode::kJSLessThan ||
+         node->opcode() == IrOpcode::kJSLessThanOrEqual);
+  Builtins::Name builtin_id;
+  const FeedbackParameter& p = FeedbackParameterOf(node->op());
+  if (CollectFeedbackInGenericLowering() && p.feedback().IsValid()) {
+    Node* feedback_vector = jsgraph()->HeapConstant(p.feedback().vector);
+    Node* slot = jsgraph()->UintPtrConstant(p.feedback().slot.ToInt());
+    node->InsertInput(zone(), 2, slot);
+    node->InsertInput(zone(), 3, feedback_vector);
+    builtin_id = builtin_with_feedback;
+  } else {
+    builtin_id = builtin_without_feedback;
+  }
+
+  CallDescriptor::Flags flags = FrameStateFlagForCall(node);
+  Callable callable = Builtins::CallableFor(isolate(), builtin_id);
+  ReplaceWithStubCall(node, callable, flags);
+}
+
+#define DEF_COMPARE_LOWERING(Name)                                     \
+  void JSGenericLowering::LowerJS##Name(Node* node) {                  \
+    ReplaceCompareOpWithBuiltinCall(node, Builtins::k##Name,           \
+                                    Builtins::k##Name##_WithFeedback); \
+  }
+DEF_COMPARE_LOWERING(Equal)
+DEF_COMPARE_LOWERING(GreaterThan)
+DEF_COMPARE_LOWERING(GreaterThanOrEqual)
+DEF_COMPARE_LOWERING(LessThan)
+DEF_COMPARE_LOWERING(LessThanOrEqual)
+#undef DEF_COMPARE_LOWERING
+
+void JSGenericLowering::LowerJSStrictEqual(Node* node) {
+  // The === operator doesn't need the current context.
+  NodeProperties::ReplaceContextInput(node, jsgraph()->NoContextConstant());
+  node->RemoveInput(4);  // control
+
+  Builtins::Name builtin_id;
+  const FeedbackParameter& p = FeedbackParameterOf(node->op());
+  if (CollectFeedbackInGenericLowering() && p.feedback().IsValid()) {
+    Node* feedback_vector = jsgraph()->HeapConstant(p.feedback().vector);
+    Node* slot = jsgraph()->UintPtrConstant(p.feedback().slot.ToInt());
+    node->InsertInput(zone(), 2, slot);
+    node->InsertInput(zone(), 3, feedback_vector);
+    builtin_id = Builtins::kStrictEqual_WithFeedback;
+  } else {
+    builtin_id = Builtins::kStrictEqual;
+  }
+
+  Callable callable = Builtins::CallableFor(isolate(), builtin_id);
+  ReplaceWithStubCall(node, callable, CallDescriptor::kNoFlags,
+                      Operator::kEliminatable);
+}
+
 namespace {
 bool ShouldUseMegamorphicLoadBuiltin(FeedbackSource const& source,
                                      JSHeapBroker* broker) {

src/compiler/js-generic-lowering.h

@@ -45,6 +45,9 @@ class JSGenericLowering final : public AdvancedReducer {
   void ReplaceUnaryOpWithBuiltinCall(Node* node,
                                      Builtins::Name builtin_without_feedback,
                                      Builtins::Name builtin_with_feedback);
+  void ReplaceCompareOpWithBuiltinCall(Node* node,
+                                       Builtins::Name builtin_without_feedback,
+                                       Builtins::Name builtin_with_feedback);
 
   Zone* zone() const;
   Isolate* isolate() const;

src/compiler/js-heap-copy-reducer.cc

@@ -85,6 +85,28 @@ Reduction JSHeapCopyReducer::Reduce(Node* node) {
       }
       break;
     }
+    case IrOpcode::kJSBitwiseNot:
+    case IrOpcode::kJSDecrement:
+    case IrOpcode::kJSIncrement:
+    case IrOpcode::kJSNegate: {
+      FeedbackParameter const& p = FeedbackParameterOf(node->op());
+      if (p.feedback().IsValid()) {
+        broker()->ProcessFeedbackForBinaryOperation(p.feedback());
+      }
+      break;
+    }
+    case IrOpcode::kJSEqual:
+    case IrOpcode::kJSGreaterThan:
+    case IrOpcode::kJSGreaterThanOrEqual:
+    case IrOpcode::kJSLessThan:
+    case IrOpcode::kJSLessThanOrEqual:
+    case IrOpcode::kJSStrictEqual: {
+      FeedbackParameter const& p = FeedbackParameterOf(node->op());
+      if (p.feedback().IsValid()) {
+        broker()->ProcessFeedbackForCompareOperation(p.feedback());
+      }
+      break;
+    }
     case IrOpcode::kJSCreateFunctionContext: {
       CreateFunctionContextParameters const& p =
           CreateFunctionContextParametersOf(node->op());

src/compiler/js-operator.h

@@ -762,8 +762,6 @@ ForInMode ForInModeOf(Operator const* op) V8_WARN_UNUSED_RESULT;
 
 BinaryOperationHint BinaryOperationHintOf(const Operator* op);
 
-CompareOperationHint CompareOperationHintOf(const Operator* op);
-
 int RegisterCountOf(Operator const* op) V8_WARN_UNUSED_RESULT;
 
 int GeneratorStoreValueCountOf(const Operator* op) V8_WARN_UNUSED_RESULT;
@@ -779,12 +777,12 @@ class V8_EXPORT_PRIVATE JSOperatorBuilder final
  public:
   explicit JSOperatorBuilder(Zone* zone);
 
-  const Operator* Equal(CompareOperationHint hint);
-  const Operator* StrictEqual(CompareOperationHint hint);
-  const Operator* LessThan(CompareOperationHint hint);
-  const Operator* GreaterThan(CompareOperationHint hint);
-  const Operator* LessThanOrEqual(CompareOperationHint hint);
-  const Operator* GreaterThanOrEqual(CompareOperationHint hint);
+  const Operator* Equal(FeedbackSource const& feedback);
+  const Operator* StrictEqual(FeedbackSource const& feedback);
+  const Operator* LessThan(FeedbackSource const& feedback);
+  const Operator* GreaterThan(FeedbackSource const& feedback);
+  const Operator* LessThanOrEqual(FeedbackSource const& feedback);
+  const Operator* GreaterThanOrEqual(FeedbackSource const& feedback);
 
   const Operator* BitwiseOr();
   const Operator* BitwiseXor();

src/compiler/js-typed-lowering.cc

@@ -38,7 +38,7 @@ class JSBinopReduction final {
 
   bool GetCompareNumberOperationHint(NumberOperationHint* hint) {
     DCHECK_EQ(1, node_->op()->EffectOutputCount());
-    switch (CompareOperationHintOf(node_->op())) {
+    switch (GetCompareOperationHint(node_)) {
       case CompareOperationHint::kSignedSmall:
         *hint = NumberOperationHint::kSignedSmall;
         return true;
@@ -66,36 +66,34 @@ class JSBinopReduction final {
 
   bool IsInternalizedStringCompareOperation() {
     DCHECK_EQ(1, node_->op()->EffectOutputCount());
-    return (CompareOperationHintOf(node_->op()) ==
+    return (GetCompareOperationHint(node_) ==
             CompareOperationHint::kInternalizedString) &&
            BothInputsMaybe(Type::InternalizedString());
   }
 
   bool IsReceiverCompareOperation() {
     DCHECK_EQ(1, node_->op()->EffectOutputCount());
-    return (CompareOperationHintOf(node_->op()) ==
+    return (GetCompareOperationHint(node_) ==
             CompareOperationHint::kReceiver) &&
            BothInputsMaybe(Type::Receiver());
   }
 
   bool IsReceiverOrNullOrUndefinedCompareOperation() {
     DCHECK_EQ(1, node_->op()->EffectOutputCount());
-    return (CompareOperationHintOf(node_->op()) ==
+    return (GetCompareOperationHint(node_) ==
             CompareOperationHint::kReceiverOrNullOrUndefined) &&
            BothInputsMaybe(Type::ReceiverOrNullOrUndefined());
   }
 
   bool IsStringCompareOperation() {
     DCHECK_EQ(1, node_->op()->EffectOutputCount());
-    return (CompareOperationHintOf(node_->op()) ==
-            CompareOperationHint::kString) &&
+    return (GetCompareOperationHint(node_) == CompareOperationHint::kString) &&
            BothInputsMaybe(Type::String());
   }
 
   bool IsSymbolCompareOperation() {
     DCHECK_EQ(1, node_->op()->EffectOutputCount());
-    return (CompareOperationHintOf(node_->op()) ==
-            CompareOperationHint::kSymbol) &&
+    return (GetCompareOperationHint(node_) == CompareOperationHint::kSymbol) &&
            BothInputsMaybe(Type::Symbol());
   }
 
@@ -417,6 +415,11 @@ class JSBinopReduction final {
     return node;
   }
 
+  CompareOperationHint GetCompareOperationHint(Node* node) const {
+    const FeedbackParameter& p = FeedbackParameterOf(node->op());
+    return lowering_->broker()->GetFeedbackForCompareOperation(p.feedback());
+  }
+
   void update_effect(Node* effect) {
     NodeProperties::ReplaceEffectInput(node_, effect);
   }

src/objects/feedback-vector.cc

@@ -326,6 +326,25 @@ Handle<FeedbackVector> FeedbackVector::New(
   return result;
 }
 
+// static
+Handle<FeedbackVector> FeedbackVector::NewWithOneCompareSlotForTesting(
+    Zone* zone, Isolate* isolate) {
+  FeedbackVectorSpec one_slot(zone);
+  one_slot.AddCompareICSlot();
+
+  Handle<FeedbackMetadata> metadata = FeedbackMetadata::New(isolate, &one_slot);
+  Handle<SharedFunctionInfo> shared =
+      isolate->factory()->NewSharedFunctionInfoForBuiltin(
+          isolate->factory()->empty_string(), Builtins::kIllegal);
+  // Set the raw feedback metadata to circumvent checks that we are not
+  // overwriting existing metadata.
+  shared->set_raw_outer_scope_info_or_feedback_metadata(*metadata);
+  Handle<ClosureFeedbackCellArray> closure_feedback_cell_array =
+      ClosureFeedbackCellArray::New(isolate, shared);
+
+  return FeedbackVector::New(isolate, shared, closure_feedback_cell_array);
+}
+
 // static
 void FeedbackVector::AddToVectorsForProfilingTools(
     Isolate* isolate, Handle<FeedbackVector> vector) {

src/objects/feedback-vector.h

@@ -264,6 +264,9 @@ class FeedbackVector : public HeapObject {
       Isolate* isolate, Handle<SharedFunctionInfo> shared,
       Handle<ClosureFeedbackCellArray> closure_feedback_cell_array);
 
+  V8_EXPORT_PRIVATE static Handle<FeedbackVector>
+  NewWithOneCompareSlotForTesting(Zone* zone, Isolate* isolate);
+
 #define DEFINE_SLOT_KIND_PREDICATE(Name) \
   bool Name(FeedbackSlot slot) const { return Name##Kind(GetKind(slot)); }
 

test/cctest/compiler/test-js-typed-lowering.cc

@@ -5,6 +5,7 @@
 #include "src/codegen/tick-counter.h"
 #include "src/compiler/js-graph.h"
 #include "src/compiler/js-heap-broker.h"
+#include "src/compiler/js-heap-copy-reducer.h"
 #include "src/compiler/js-typed-lowering.h"
 #include "src/compiler/machine-operator.h"
 #include "src/compiler/node-properties.h"
@@ -55,7 +56,6 @@ class JSTypedLoweringTester : public HandleAndZoneScope {
   Typer typer;
   Node* context_node;
   BinaryOperationHint const binop_hints = BinaryOperationHint::kAny;
-  CompareOperationHint const compare_hints = CompareOperationHint::kAny;
 
   Node* Parameter(Type t, int32_t index = 0) {
     Node* n = graph.NewNode(common.Parameter(index), graph.start());
@@ -89,6 +89,8 @@ class JSTypedLoweringTester : public HandleAndZoneScope {
   }
 
   Node* reduce(Node* node) {
+    JSHeapCopyReducer heap_copy_reducer(&js_heap_broker);
+    CHECK(!heap_copy_reducer.Reduce(node).Changed());
     JSGraph jsgraph(main_isolate(), &graph, &common, &javascript, &simplified,
                     &machine);
     // TODO(titzer): mock the GraphReducer here for better unit testing.
@@ -564,18 +566,28 @@ TEST(JSToString_replacement) {
   }
 }
 
+namespace {
+
+FeedbackSource FeedbackSourceWithOneCompareSlot(JSTypedLoweringTester* R) {
+  return FeedbackSource{FeedbackVector::NewWithOneCompareSlotForTesting(
+                            R->main_zone(), R->main_isolate()),
+                        FeedbackSlot{0}};
+}
+
+}  // namespace
+
 TEST(StringComparison) {
   JSTypedLoweringTester R;
+  FeedbackSource feedback_source = FeedbackSourceWithOneCompareSlot(&R);
 
-  const Operator* ops[] = {
-      R.javascript.LessThan(CompareOperationHint::kAny),
-      R.simplified.StringLessThan(),
-      R.javascript.LessThanOrEqual(CompareOperationHint::kAny),
-      R.simplified.StringLessThanOrEqual(),
-      R.javascript.GreaterThan(CompareOperationHint::kAny),
-      R.simplified.StringLessThan(),
-      R.javascript.GreaterThanOrEqual(CompareOperationHint::kAny),
-      R.simplified.StringLessThanOrEqual()};
+  const Operator* ops[] = {R.javascript.LessThan(feedback_source),
+                           R.simplified.StringLessThan(),
+                           R.javascript.LessThanOrEqual(feedback_source),
+                           R.simplified.StringLessThanOrEqual(),
+                           R.javascript.GreaterThan(feedback_source),
+                           R.simplified.StringLessThan(),
+                           R.javascript.GreaterThanOrEqual(feedback_source),
+                           R.simplified.StringLessThanOrEqual()};
 
   for (size_t i = 0; i < arraysize(kStringTypes); i++) {
     Node* p0 = R.Parameter(kStringTypes[i], 0);
@@ -615,16 +627,16 @@ static void CheckIsConvertedToNumber(Node* val, Node* converted) {
 
 TEST(NumberComparison) {
   JSTypedLoweringTester R;
+  FeedbackSource feedback_source = FeedbackSourceWithOneCompareSlot(&R);
 
-  const Operator* ops[] = {
-      R.javascript.LessThan(CompareOperationHint::kAny),
-      R.simplified.NumberLessThan(),
-      R.javascript.LessThanOrEqual(CompareOperationHint::kAny),
-      R.simplified.NumberLessThanOrEqual(),
-      R.javascript.GreaterThan(CompareOperationHint::kAny),
-      R.simplified.NumberLessThan(),
-      R.javascript.GreaterThanOrEqual(CompareOperationHint::kAny),
-      R.simplified.NumberLessThanOrEqual()};
+  const Operator* ops[] = {R.javascript.LessThan(feedback_source),
+                           R.simplified.NumberLessThan(),
+                           R.javascript.LessThanOrEqual(feedback_source),
+                           R.simplified.NumberLessThanOrEqual(),
+                           R.javascript.GreaterThan(feedback_source),
+                           R.simplified.NumberLessThan(),
+                           R.javascript.GreaterThanOrEqual(feedback_source),
+                           R.simplified.NumberLessThanOrEqual()};
 
   Node* const p0 = R.Parameter(Type::Number(), 0);
   Node* const p1 = R.Parameter(Type::Number(), 1);
@@ -648,6 +660,7 @@ TEST(NumberComparison) {
 
 TEST(MixedComparison1) {
   JSTypedLoweringTester R;
+  FeedbackSource feedback_source = FeedbackSourceWithOneCompareSlot(&R);
 
   Type types[] = {Type::Number(), Type::String(),
                   Type::Union(Type::Number(), Type::String(), R.main_zone())};
@@ -658,8 +671,7 @@ TEST(MixedComparison1) {
     for (size_t j = 0; j < arraysize(types); j++) {
       Node* p1 = R.Parameter(types[j], 1);
       {
-        const Operator* less_than =
-            R.javascript.LessThan(CompareOperationHint::kAny);
+        const Operator* less_than = R.javascript.LessThan(feedback_source);
         Node* cmp = R.Binop(less_than, p0, p1);
         Node* r = R.reduce(cmp);
         if (types[i].Is(Type::String()) && types[j].Is(Type::String())) {
@@ -801,14 +813,14 @@ class BinopEffectsTester {
 // Helper function for strict and non-strict equality reductions.
 void CheckEqualityReduction(JSTypedLoweringTester* R, bool strict, Node* l,
                             Node* r, IrOpcode::Value expected) {
+  FeedbackSource feedback_source = FeedbackSourceWithOneCompareSlot(R);
   for (int j = 0; j < 2; j++) {
     Node* p0 = j == 0 ? l : r;
     Node* p1 = j == 1 ? l : r;
 
     {
-      const Operator* op =
-          strict ? R->javascript.StrictEqual(CompareOperationHint::kAny)
-                 : R->javascript.Equal(CompareOperationHint::kAny);
+      const Operator* op = strict ? R->javascript.StrictEqual(feedback_source)
+                                  : R->javascript.Equal(feedback_source);
       Node* eq = R->Binop(op, p0, p1);
       Node* r = R->reduce(eq);
       R->CheckBinop(expected, r);
@@ -870,9 +882,10 @@ TEST(StringEquality) {
 
 TEST(RemovePureNumberBinopEffects) {
   JSTypedLoweringTester R;
+  FeedbackSource feedback_source = FeedbackSourceWithOneCompareSlot(&R);
 
   const Operator* ops[] = {
-      R.javascript.Equal(R.compare_hints),
+      R.javascript.Equal(feedback_source),
       R.simplified.NumberEqual(),
       R.javascript.Add(R.binop_hints),
       R.simplified.NumberAdd(),
@@ -884,9 +897,9 @@ TEST(RemovePureNumberBinopEffects) {
       R.simplified.NumberDivide(),
       R.javascript.Modulus(),
       R.simplified.NumberModulus(),
-      R.javascript.LessThan(R.compare_hints),
+      R.javascript.LessThan(feedback_source),
       R.simplified.NumberLessThan(),
-      R.javascript.LessThanOrEqual(R.compare_hints),
+      R.javascript.LessThanOrEqual(feedback_source),
       R.simplified.NumberLessThanOrEqual(),
   };
 
@@ -1040,6 +1053,7 @@ TEST(Int32AddNarrowing) {
 
 TEST(Int32Comparisons) {
   JSTypedLoweringTester R;
+  FeedbackSource feedback_source = FeedbackSourceWithOneCompareSlot(&R);
 
   struct Entry {
     const Operator* js_op;
@@ -1047,13 +1061,13 @@ TEST(Int32Comparisons) {
     bool commute;
   };
 
-  Entry ops[] = {{R.javascript.LessThan(R.compare_hints),
+  Entry ops[] = {{R.javascript.LessThan(feedback_source),
                   R.simplified.NumberLessThan(), false},
-                 {R.javascript.LessThanOrEqual(R.compare_hints),
+                 {R.javascript.LessThanOrEqual(feedback_source),
                   R.simplified.NumberLessThanOrEqual(), false},
-                 {R.javascript.GreaterThan(R.compare_hints),
+                 {R.javascript.GreaterThan(feedback_source),
                   R.simplified.NumberLessThan(), true},
-                 {R.javascript.GreaterThanOrEqual(R.compare_hints),
+                 {R.javascript.GreaterThanOrEqual(feedback_source),
                   R.simplified.NumberLessThanOrEqual(), true}};
 
   for (size_t o = 0; o < arraysize(ops); o++) {

test/unittests/compiler/js-typed-lowering-unittest.cc

@@ -164,6 +164,16 @@ TEST_F(JSTypedLoweringTest, JSToStringWithBoolean) {
 // -----------------------------------------------------------------------------
 // JSStrictEqual
 
+namespace {
+
+FeedbackSource FeedbackSourceWithOneCompareSlot(JSTypedLoweringTest* R) {
+  return FeedbackSource{
+      FeedbackVector::NewWithOneCompareSlotForTesting(R->zone(), R->isolate()),
+      FeedbackSlot{0}};
+}
+
+}  // namespace
+
 TEST_F(JSTypedLoweringTest, JSStrictEqualWithTheHole) {
   Node* const the_hole = HeapConstant(factory()->the_hole_value());
   Node* const context = UndefinedConstant();
@@ -171,9 +181,9 @@ TEST_F(JSTypedLoweringTest, JSStrictEqualWithTheHole) {
   Node* const control = graph()->start();
   TRACED_FOREACH(Type, type, kJSTypes) {
     Node* const lhs = Parameter(type);
-    Reduction r = Reduce(
-        graph()->NewNode(javascript()->StrictEqual(CompareOperationHint::kAny),
-                         lhs, the_hole, context, effect, control));
+    Reduction r = Reduce(graph()->NewNode(
+        javascript()->StrictEqual(FeedbackSourceWithOneCompareSlot(this)), lhs,
+        the_hole, context, effect, control));
     ASSERT_FALSE(r.Changed());
   }
 }
@@ -185,9 +195,9 @@ TEST_F(JSTypedLoweringTest, JSStrictEqualWithUnique) {
   Node* const context = Parameter(Type::Any(), 2);
   Node* const effect = graph()->start();
   Node* const control = graph()->start();
-  Reduction r = Reduce(
-      graph()->NewNode(javascript()->StrictEqual(CompareOperationHint::kAny),
-                       lhs, rhs, context, effect, control));
+  Reduction r = Reduce(graph()->NewNode(
+      javascript()->StrictEqual(FeedbackSourceWithOneCompareSlot(this)), lhs,
+      rhs, context, effect, control));
   ASSERT_TRUE(r.Changed());
   EXPECT_THAT(r.replacement(), IsReferenceEqual(lhs, rhs));
 }

test/unittests/compiler/typer-unittest.cc

@@ -362,9 +362,20 @@ TEST_F(TyperTest, TypeJSShiftRight) {
   TestBinaryBitOp(javascript_.ShiftRight(), shift_right);
 }
 
+namespace {
+
+FeedbackSource FeedbackSourceWithOneCompareSlot(TyperTest* R) {
+  return FeedbackSource{
+      FeedbackVector::NewWithOneCompareSlotForTesting(R->zone(), R->isolate()),
+      FeedbackSlot{0}};
+}
+
+}  // namespace
+
 TEST_F(TyperTest, TypeJSLessThan) {
-  TestBinaryCompareOp(javascript_.LessThan(CompareOperationHint::kAny),
-                      std::less<double>());
+  TestBinaryCompareOp(
+      javascript_.LessThan(FeedbackSourceWithOneCompareSlot(this)),
+      std::less<double>());
 }
 
 TEST_F(TyperTest, TypeNumberLessThan) {
@@ -378,8 +389,9 @@ TEST_F(TyperTest, TypeSpeculativeNumberLessThan) {
 }
 
 TEST_F(TyperTest, TypeJSLessThanOrEqual) {
-  TestBinaryCompareOp(javascript_.LessThanOrEqual(CompareOperationHint::kAny),
-                      std::less_equal<double>());
+  TestBinaryCompareOp(
+      javascript_.LessThanOrEqual(FeedbackSourceWithOneCompareSlot(this)),
+      std::less_equal<double>());
 }
 
 TEST_F(TyperTest, TypeNumberLessThanOrEqual) {
@@ -394,19 +406,20 @@ TEST_F(TyperTest, TypeSpeculativeNumberLessThanOrEqual) {
 }
 
 TEST_F(TyperTest, TypeJSGreaterThan) {
-  TestBinaryCompareOp(javascript_.GreaterThan(CompareOperationHint::kAny),
-                      std::greater<double>());
+  TestBinaryCompareOp(
+      javascript_.GreaterThan(FeedbackSourceWithOneCompareSlot(this)),
+      std::greater<double>());
 }
 
 
 TEST_F(TyperTest, TypeJSGreaterThanOrEqual) {
   TestBinaryCompareOp(
-      javascript_.GreaterThanOrEqual(CompareOperationHint::kAny),
+      javascript_.GreaterThanOrEqual(FeedbackSourceWithOneCompareSlot(this)),
       std::greater_equal<double>());
 }
 
 TEST_F(TyperTest, TypeJSEqual) {
-  TestBinaryCompareOp(javascript_.Equal(CompareOperationHint::kAny),
+  TestBinaryCompareOp(javascript_.Equal(FeedbackSourceWithOneCompareSlot(this)),
                       std::equal_to<double>());
 }
 
@@ -422,8 +435,9 @@ TEST_F(TyperTest, TypeSpeculativeNumberEqual) {
 
 // For numbers there's no difference between strict and non-strict equality.
 TEST_F(TyperTest, TypeJSStrictEqual) {
-  TestBinaryCompareOp(javascript_.StrictEqual(CompareOperationHint::kAny),
-                      std::equal_to<double>());
+  TestBinaryCompareOp(
+      javascript_.StrictEqual(FeedbackSourceWithOneCompareSlot(this)),
+      std::equal_to<double>());
 }
 
 //------------------------------------------------------------------------------
@@ -442,9 +456,10 @@ TEST_MONOTONICITY(ToString)
 #undef TEST_MONOTONICITY
 
 // JS BINOPs with CompareOperationHint
-#define TEST_MONOTONICITY(name)                                           \
-  TEST_F(TyperTest, Monotonicity_##name) {                                \
-    TestBinaryMonotonicity(javascript_.name(CompareOperationHint::kAny)); \
+#define TEST_MONOTONICITY(name)                                    \
+  TEST_F(TyperTest, Monotonicity_##name) {                         \
+    TestBinaryMonotonicity(                                        \
+        javascript_.name(FeedbackSourceWithOneCompareSlot(this))); \
   }
 TEST_MONOTONICITY(Equal)
 TEST_MONOTONICITY(StrictEqual)